“My face isn’t a crowd,” says Kiriko (Riku Kurokouchi) at an audition for the latest film by director Kobayashi (Tatsuhiro Yamaoka) in Sion Sono’s Red Post on Escher Street. “I have my own face.” she continues.
The metanarrative nature of films about performance can take many forms, and it is far from novel in contemporary cinema. In a sense, one could make the argument that almost every film becomes a metanarrative on the idea of performance in today’s high-capitalist commercial landscape. The Actor has been commoditized and fetishized, and while Barthes announced the death of the Author—and put a distinct postmodern rhetorical spin on an old debate—the Actor is very much still alive, maybe more so now than ever before. Barthes’ pronouncement on the Author essentially functioned to separate the text (and its meaning) from the writer and their intentions—to put it reductively. This is in stark opposition to the Actor of the now: talk shows, newspapers, podcasts, Tiktoks and other avenues of exposure are the norm, and it seems more and more that we see The Actor on the screen rather than the character they inhabit. This is, of course, a subjective and personal issue and one a lot of people may not recognize for themselves, but their faces sell; we go to see the names on the poster and miss them when they are gone. This commodification of the actor—of their body and their labor—and our engagement with it as an audience was commented upon by Walter Benjamin sporadically in the 1930s. Benjamin talked about the contemporaneity and historicity of this problematization, but to read his thoughts today, it seems like an eerie prophetic vision—more on this later.

This perception of the role of the Actor, if one subscribes to it, might explain why we’ve seen so many films deal with the idea of performance in their explicit texts in the past few years. From Clouds of Sils Maria (Olivier Assayas) and Holy Motors (Leos Carax) to Birdman (Alejandro González Iñárritu) and The Twentieth Century (Matthew Rankin). A collection of films that are worlds apart yet share one commonality in their obsession with the performance, or rather, their obsession with the phenomenological nature of the filmed performance. Key to this commonality is the value they place on the cinematic semiotics of performance. They are very much concerned with the formal signifiers of performance first—what does it mean to move or gesture in a certain way, when filmed—and the sociological theories second—what can performance for a film tell us about our real, lived experiences, and how an audience responds to said movements and gestures.
Sion Sono’s Red Post on Escher Street and Natsuka Kusano’s Domains are both explicitly about the act of performance for a film but approach it from distinct opposite directions. Sono’s film is an outrageously funny and transgressive tale of the extras in the film industry—the body that is decorative—and the immense pressure and pleasure of populating the onscreen space without taking up said space; a specter that neither haunts nor registers for the main actors, but still makes them less alone. It’s a Sono film through and through, with all the extravagant idiosyncrasies that entail, from the kinetic narrative momentum to the absurd theater of confrontation. The film is structurally ambivalent and rushes off in any direction at a moment’s notice, to follow a new extra which we then get to know. Title cards with their names intercut the different scenarios, which all lead back to the main film production and a climax that is fully in control of the structural ambivalence and the effects it has.
Kusano’s film is the opposite. Stripped bare of all artifice, Domains is about repetition. The roughly three-hour run time is almost exclusively set at a table read, where the story unfolds as our actors read their scenes and their lines together, again and again. It is constructed around a tragic dialogue—which I recommend you do not read about until you’ve seen the film—and each repetition is a variation in intonation, tone, phrasing, etc. Their confidence and familiarity with the dialogue grow for every reset, and we see them inhabit themselves more and more. The challenge of the film comes not so much from the hours of repetition, but from the confrontation of our expectations on what the role of the actor is supposed to be. To further accentuate this idea of the actor-performer/performer actor dynamic, we get a scene in which they are literally doubled in a mirror. The actor becomes the performer becomes the actor becomes the self.

The repetitive nature may at first seem like a puzzle or mystery to be solved through careful analysis of gestures or words—maybe we can comprehend Aki’s (Asami Shibuya) actions through her language or maybe we’ll understand the dreadful circumstances the film is constructed around. This is of course part of the film’s strength, but it’s not the reason it works. The repetition, the careful alteration of details in each echoing scene is not so much about a diegetic mystery, but rather about interpersonal interactions and how we listen to those around us—much like Sono’s film is about how we find our own place and voice in this high-capitalist culture, where our own faces, voices, and identities have been commoditized just like our labor.
The reason these strange artifacts deserve to be appraised together is their empathetic and theoretical approaches to the idea of performance for a film, and their intertextual politicization of our own bodies. In Cinema and Experience: Siegfried Kracauer, Walter Benjamin, and Theodor W. Adorno, the German film historian Miriam Bratu Hansen engage with Benjamin’s various texts on the idea of the audience’s participation in the commodification of art. Hansen writes while quoting Benjamin: “The capitalist entertainment market, where the screen actor “offers not only his labor but his entire self, with skin and hair, with heart and kidneys, is beyond his reach” (SW 4:261; GS 1:491–92); it makes him a human commodity at the mercy of buyers who remain invisible to him.” This may seem superfluous when stripped of the context of the essay in question or Benjamin’s overall project, but it essentially functions as a continuation of Benjamin’s concerns about the proletariat’s consumption of art that, unbeknownst to them or otherwise, either accentuate class divides and strips us of class solidarity or erases the idea completely—which is another mode of accentuation. Benjamin acknowledges that the art consumer, particularly that of the filmgoing audience, cannot be easily categorized in a single class which in effect makes it a challenge for the lower classes to organize or mobilize in their consumption of art, which therefore means the production of art which only seeks revenue or capital, can more easily spread division, confusion, and distraction.


Now, this rant on Benjamin may be incoherent and nonsensical, but there is a point to it that connects Red Post on Escher Street and Domains. These films are of course created on the backs of the performers’ labor and faces (we can hope it’s done without exploitation), but they are actively engaging with the idea of their performance and the cause and effect it has in the real world. Sono’s film climaxes on-set of the in-film production, where the sporadic structure that has led us here, confronts the entire idea of the commodification of the actor. There’s a burst of creative, political, and empathetic energy that culminates in an acknowledgment of it all. It doesn’t only recognize the class divide and the danger of erasure in our society, it is a direct call for class solidarity and love.
Domains’ is much more subdued, yet equally powerful and truthful. The repetition of scenes and dialogues essentially asks and prepares us to be familiar and comfortable with our own skin, voice, and labor. The performances repeat and repeat, and the familiarity with which we—the dethatched audience—have with the characters—the active performers—is rare. Domains isn’t transgressive in the sense that it calls for a revolution—whether Sono’s film does is up for consideration—but it is transgressive in the sense that it challenges the audiences’ patience and time with repetition, to arrive at the truth that is solidarity.
Whereas Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, by Quentin Tarantino descends into a ridiculous fairytale, where the artifice of seismic proportions only serve the function of entertainment, Sono’s Once Upon a Time on Escher Street ends with an astonishing and almost frightening confrontation of the self and a beautiful testimony to the idea of self-realization and actualization in the face of the insurmountable odds of our day to day existence and the dehumanizing system that has been created to sustain capitalism above humanism.